Migration Industries and Developmental States in East Asia

Surak, Kristin

Abstract

The emerging field of migration industry studies has refocused attention on the entrepreneurial infrastructures—labor recruitment, money-lending, transportation, remittance, documentation, and communication services—vital for directing movement between here and there. Work in this vein has concentrated largely on illegal and irregular activities, and thus presents the state as a supportive or inhibitive context for such industries to grow, but not as an active partner in their development. Investigating legal migration schemes, however, offers the opportunity to elaborate the forms of state involvement. This chapter examines how the governments of Taiwan, Japan, and South Korea cooperate with migration entrepreneurs and enterprises to manage the labor and marriage migration schemes directing flows from China, Southeast Asia, and Latin America. I show that, as in prior studies, the state becomes a platform for the development of migration industries when visas have few restrictions. The game is different, however, when visas are limited. In formal or informal guestworker schemes, the state may become a principal charging agents—brokers, visa handlers, employers—to implement its programs, thereby saving resources, strengthening control through market mechanisms, and creating a protective “corporate veil.” Finally, the state may become a piggybacker that attaches itself to grass-roots migration industry sectors and makes use of the existing infrastructure of migration businesses for its own ends. Civil society groups can block some of the most exploitative elements of such schemes, but their efforts are stymied as the state becomes increasingly invested in these partnerships.

Citation

Surak, K. (2012). Migration Industries and Developmental States in East Asia. In T. Gammeltoft-Hansen, & N. Nyberg Sorensen (Eds.), The Migration Industry and the Commercialization of International Migration (89-110). Routledge

• Publication Date: Jan 1, 2012
• Deposit Date: Feb 11, 2014
• Publisher: Routledge
• Pages: 89-110
• Book Title: The Migration Industry and the Commercialization of International Migration
• ISBN: 9780415623780
• Keywords: international migration, migration industry, East Asia